Deciding which films to watch: Are critics' ratings useful?
Deciding which films to watch Should we go by film critics and their ratings? The only true measure of a film’s worth to a viewer is the utility it produces for her. This is a deeply personal and subjective measure and will necessarily vary between individuals. Remember that friend who is a sucker for rom-coms, however cheesy? And those others, bright folks by all other accounts, who repeatedly fall for neuralizers and infinity stones. By extension, the same holds for film critics. Whatever some of them may believe, they are not higher order beings, and are likely to succumb to the same subjective influences as all the rest of us. I am sure many of us have unwittingly subjected ourselves to the torture of watching films from a critic’s “top 10” selection. Still, there is this pervasive belief that critics are somehow able to identify the films that you’ll like, as against viewer ratings which are produced by “ordinary”, “uninformed” folk, and are therefore useless. S...